BECDIR CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2004
District: 10
Project Number: 020236
PID Number: 23900
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-0236(02)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: VIN - CR 38A - 0.36/Various
Description: Covered Bridges
Issues: Constructive acceleration, Mitigation, Precaution against damage, Act of God, Dispute Resolution Process, Claim after final change order, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Delay - owner caused
Decision/Recommendation: 10-0236(02)-01
C J MAHAN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LLC
Year: 2002
District: 9
Project Number: 010178
PID Number: 11858
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 09-0178(01)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: SCI - USR 23-0.00 (City of Portsmouth)
Description: Erection Engineering Delay and Cost
Issues: CPM Progress Schedule, Delay - owner caused, Errors and Omissions
Decision/Recommendation: 09-0178(01)-01
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2003
District: 10
Project Number: 013001
PID Number: 21053
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-3001(01)-1001-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: ATH - USR 33 - 10.41
Description: Project Completion Delay - HOOH, Extended Cost
Issues: Engineer-ordered suspension, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Overhead (home/field office), Extra work, Change order policy, Interest
Decision/Recommendation: 10-3001(01)-1001-04
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2003
District: 6
Project Number: 020069
PID Number: 4666
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-0069(02)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: FRA - IR 670 - 3.17/Various - Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Drilled Shafts and Tie Backs
Issues: Differing site conditions, Drilled shafts, Tie back retaining walls, Means and methods, Winter protection
Decision/Recommendation: 06-0069(02)-01
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2000
District: 5
Project Number: 970139
PID Number: 14143
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-0139(97)-0897-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: COS - USR 36 - 27.54
Description: Pipe Removal Payment
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Pipe removal, Pre-bid question
Decision/Recommendation: 05-0139(97)-0897-03
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2002
District: 8
Project Number: 010158
PID Number: 6525
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 08-0158(01)-0102-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: HAM - SR 4-4.000 (Paddock Road) (City of Cincinnati)
Description: Extent of Repair/Removal of Honeycomb Concrete
Decision/Recommendation: 08-0158(01)-0102-01
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2002
District: 10
Project Number: 013001
PID Number: 21053
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-3001(01)-1001-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: ATH - USR 33 - 10.41
Description: Project Completion Delay - HOOH, Extended Cost
Issues: Engineer-ordered suspension, Extra work, Change order policy, Interest, Inefficiency/Loss of productivity
Decision/Recommendation: 10-3001(01)-1001-04
COMPLETE GENERAL CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2001
District: 5
Project Number: 970139
PID Number: 14143
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-0139(97)-0897-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: COS - USR 36 - 27.54
Description: Pipe Removal Payment
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Pipe removal, Pre-bid question
Decision/Recommendation: 05-0139(97)-0897-03
FRU-CON CONSTRUCTION CORPORATION
Year: 2004
District: 2
Project Number: 010493
PID Number: 20208
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: D2.025
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: LUC - IR 280 - 2.96
Description: Discrepancy in Concrete Quantity for Precast Segmental Concrete
Issues: Discrepancy in quantity, Signif. change in scope/character of work, Notice
Decision/Recommendation: D2.025
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2006
District: 12
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Bridge Painting - Surface Cleanliness
Issues: Inspection, Acceptance (express/implied), Industry standard, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Mitigation
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-01
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2006
District: 12
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Bridge Painting - Testing Equipment
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Inspection, Industry standard
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-02
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2006
District: 12
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Bridge Painting - Heating Costs
Issues: Defective specification, Notice, Mitigation
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-03
GERONIMO PAINTING CO INC
Year: 2006
District: 12
Project Number: 050107
PID Number: 22130
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-050107-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - SR 2 - 14.41 (City of Cleveland)
Description: Fuel Price Escalation
Issues: Material escalation
Decision/Recommendation: 12-050107-04
GREAT LAKES CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2003
District: 4
Project Number: 000323
PID Number: 13458
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0323(00)-1102-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: SUM - IR 76 - 24.799/0.000 (Cities of Akron & Tallmadge)
Description: Thin Pavement
Issues: Thin concrete pavement, Unjust enrichment
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0323(00)-1102-02
GREAT LAKES CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2003
District: 4
Project Number: 000323
PID Number: 13458
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0323(00)-1102-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: SUM - IR 76 - 24.799/0.000 (Cities of Akron & Tallmadge)
Description: Concrete Pavement with Warranty
Issues: Concrete pavement w/warranty
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0323(00)-1102-01
ICARUS INDUSTRIAL PAINTING & CONTRACTING CO INC
Year: 2002
District: 9
Project Number: 990465
PID Number: 19781
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 09-0465(99)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: JAC - S.R. 32 - 11.75/VARIOUS (City of Ironton) (Village of Hanging Rock)
Description: Bridge Painting
Issues: Dispute Resolution Process
Decision/Recommendation: 09-0465(99)-01
JOHN R JURGENSEN COMPANY
Year: 2000
District: 8
Project Number: 003012
PID Number: 19786
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 08-3012(00)-0201-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: HAM - IR 275 - 32.27/0.00 (Cities of Montgomery & Milford) (Village of Indian Hill)
Description: Design-Build Scope of Work - Temporary Shoring
Issues: Design-Build, Specifications (design/performance), Contract interpretation/ambiguity
Decision/Recommendation: 08-3012(00)-0201-02
JOHN R JURGENSEN COMPANY
Year: 2005
District: 8
Project Number: 030002
PID Number: 17381
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 08-030002-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: BUT - CR 115 - 0.00 (City of Fairfield)
Description: Concrete Testing and Inspection
Issues: Notice, Duty to examine Bid Documents, Errors and Omissions, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, Signif. change in scope/character of work, Mitigation, Duty to coordinate subs, Equitable Adjustment
Decision/Recommendation: 08-030002-01
JOHN R JURGENSEN COMPANY
Year: 2006
District: 6
Project Number: 030134
PID Number: 6225
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: n/a
Dispute Resolution Forum:
Location: FAY - IR 71 - 0.00 (Villages of Octa & Jeffersonville)
Description: High Performance Concrete For New Bridge Decks With Warranty Appeal
Issues: Warranty
Decision/Recommendation: n/a
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2005
District: 3
Project Number: 049077
PID Number: 78096
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 03-049077-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: MRW - IR 71 - 19.54/0.00
Description: Joint Repairs
Issues: Dispute Resolution Process, Type A Emergency, Inspection, Acceptance (express/implied), Workmanlike construction, Responsibility for project, Burden of proof
Decision/Recommendation: 03-049077-01
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2004
District: 5
Project Number: 020068
PID Number: 13281
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 05-0068(02)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: FAI - USR 33 - 0.41 (City of Springdale)
Description: Ameritech Utility Delay
Issues: Utility delay, CPM Progress Schedule, Non-responsiveness as approval/acceptance, Overhead (home/field office), Extra work, Notice, Delay - critical/non-critical, CPM calendar/logic changes
Decision/Recommendation: 05-0068(02)-01
KOKOSING CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC
Year: 2004
District: 7
Project Number: 010560
PID Number: 18249
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 07-0560(01)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: MOT - IR 75-29.305
Description: Ameritech Utility Delay
Issues: Utility delay, Mitigation, Notice, CPM Progress Schedule
Decision/Recommendation: 07-0560(01)-01
MAHAN/NATIONAL A JOINT VENTURE
Year: 2006
District: 10
Project Number: 020510
PID Number: 19714
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-020510-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: MEG - USR 33-15.70 (Village of Pomeroy)
Description: Tower Leg Concrete
Issues: Defective specification, Means and methods, Workmanlike construction, Burden of proof, Changed contract condition
Decision/Recommendation: 10-020510-02
MILLER BROS CONST INC
Year: 2003
District: 2
Project Number: 990141
PID Number: 9159
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 02-0141(99)-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: LUC - S.R. 2 - 21.24 PART 1; S.R. 2 - 27.26 (JERUSALEM ROAD) PART 2 (City of Oregon)
Description: Asphalt Pavement Rutting
Issues: Asphalt pavement rutting
Decision/Recommendation: 02-0141(99)-02
MILLER BROS CONST INC
Year: 2002
District: 2
Project Number: 990141
PID Number: 9159
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 02-0141(99)-0901-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: LUC - S.R. 2 - 21.24 PART 1; S.R. 2 - 27.26 (JERUSALEM ROAD) PART 2 (City of Oregon)
Description: Brick Salvage Value, Various Additional Costs
Decision/Recommendation: 02-0141(99)-0901-01
NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2005
District: 6
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-0163(04)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: MSE Wall Backfill Resistivity Testing
Issues: Mutual Mistake, Unjust enrichment, Reasonably close conformity, Industry standard, Past practice, Contract interpretation/ambiguity, MSE wall
Decision/Recommendation: 06-0163(04)-01
NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2006
District: 6
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-040163-03
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: Multiple Project Impacts
Issues: Inefficiency/Loss of productivity, Utility delay, Delay - owner caused, Constructive acceleration, Extra work, Change order release/waiver, Winter protection, Overhead (home/field office)
Decision/Recommendation: 06-040163-03
NATIONAL ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING COMPANY
Year: 2005
District: 6
Project Number: 040163
PID Number: 77003
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 06-0163(04)-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Dispute Review Board
Location: FRA - SR 161/IR 270-25.900/40.260-Part 1 & 2 (City of Columbus)
Description: MSE Wall Design Criteria
Issues: Contract interpretation/ambiguity, MSE wall, Incorporation by reference
Decision/Recommendation: 06-0163(04)-02
NORTHERN OHIO PAVING COMPANY
Year: 2002
District: 4
Project Number: 013002
PID Number: 22163
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-3002(01)-1119-04
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: TRU - IR 80 - 9.08
Description: Repair of Bridge Overlay
Decision/Recommendation: 04-3002(01)-1119-04
SHELLY & SANDS INC
Year: 2004
District: 4
Project Number: 030406
PID Number: 23412
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0406(03)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: POR - SR 303 - 2.73 (City of Streetsboro)
Description: Partial Depth Repairs
Issues: Signif. change in scope/character of work, Partial Depth Pavement Repair
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0406(03)-01
SMITH & JOHNSON CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2002
District: 10
Project Number: 010246
PID Number: 18288
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-0246(01)-0402-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: ATH - USR 33 - 40.981
Description: Timber Value & Production Loss
Decision/Recommendation: 10-0246(01)-0402-02
SMITH & JOHNSON CONSTRUCTION CO
Year: 2004
District: 10
Project Number: 010246
PID Number: 18288
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 10-0246(01)-0402-02
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: ATH - USR 33 - 40.981
Description: Timber Value & Production Loss
Decision/Recommendation: 10-0246(01)-0402-02
SODA CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2002
District: 4
Project Number: 990181
PID Number: 4130
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0181(99)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: MAH - S.R. 616 - 4.973 (City of Struthers)
Description: Compensation for Breach of Contract, Misc.
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0181(99)-01
VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 1999
District: 4
Project Number: 940613
PID Number: 4185
Specification Year:
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-0613(94)-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Arbitration
Location: Summit County
Description: Additional Costs of Painting Operations, Excess Sandblasting, Excess Materials
Issues: Structural steel painting, Reasonably close conformity, Inspection
Decision/Recommendation: 04-0613(94)-01
VELOTTA COMPANY
Year: 2005
District: 4
Project Number: 030534
PID Number: 21004
Specification Year: 2002
Dispute/Claim Number: 04-030534-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Deputy Director's Board
Location: POR - IR 76 - 9.50
Description: Fabrication of Structural Steel Plate Girders
Issues: Constructive acceleration, Unjust enrichment, Equitable Adjustment, Early Completion Schedule, Mitigation, Duty to coordinate subs, Voluntary Acceleration
Decision/Recommendation: 04-030534-01
WALSH CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
Year: 2006
District: 12
Project Number: 040293
PID Number: 5511
Specification Year: 1997
Dispute/Claim Number: 12-040293-01
Dispute Resolution Forum: Director's Claim Board
Location: CUY - West 3rd St. (City of Cleveland)
Description: Wire Rope Length
Issues: Disclaimer, Errors and Omissions, Shop Drawings, Acceptance (express/implied), Defective specification, Notice, Mitigation
Decision/Recommendation: 12-040293-01